I finally got around to watching Logan a few nights ago. There was a
time, not that long ago, when I wouldn't have missed something like that in the
theater, but then I saw X-Men Origins:
Wolverine. And X-Men: The Last Stand.
And The Wolverine. And, let's face
it: Days of Future Past is kind of
overrated. To my relative surprise, Logan
is a dark, violent, funny, moving film, far better than it has to be—so good,
in fact, that I started questioning my judgments of some of those other X-Men
movies. Your attitude going into experiencing a piece of art (and for our
purposes here, I'm defining "art" as anything from "Water
Lilies" to The Dark Knight Returns
to Their Eyes Were Watching God to Grand Theft Auto V to whatever Shia
Lebeouf is farting into a freezer bag as I type this) can have a significant
impact on your enjoyment. On that note, I knew I'd watched X-Men: Apocalypse at some point since it became available to
stream, but I could not, for the life of me, remember a single thing about it
other than a vaguely negative impression and that Oscar Isaac is four feet
tall. The general consensus among friends and acquaintances I've talked to
about it can be summed up as, "It's a fun movie?" with or without an
accompanying shrug. Could it be, I wondered, that I watched Apocalypse at the end of a long day, or
in a particularly bad mood, and was unduly harsh in my evaluation?
Short answer: no. This movie is
garbage. This movie makes X-Men: The Last
Stand look like Return of the Jedi
and X-Men Origins: Wolverine look
like The Godfather Part II.
Longer answer: seriously, this movie
is so bad. Like, through every scene
I was shaking my head and wondering how something so many talented people
worked on could be so shoddily constructed. There are a thousand plot holes, both
large and small. It's never clear why any of the characters are doing anything;
Apocalypse has so many powers he's functionally omnipotent, but we don't know
what they are and they're never really explained, so despite the fact that the
FATE OF THE WORLD is in the balance, it doesn't really feel like there's
anything at stake; and for a big budget summer action movie, it looks kind of
shitty. There are five writers attached, fourteen characters who have starred
in comics of their own, and they're adapting threads of… I don't know for sure,
so I'm just going to estimate 10,000 storylines from those comics; if too
many cooks spoil the broth, well, in this case they turned it into diarrhea.
We open in "Nile Valley – 3600
B.C.E." It looks like a cartoon, but there are some live-action extras in
shapeless tunics chanting something incomprehensible, which I know from being a
40-year-old virgin (don't tell my wife) is "En Sabah Nur,"
Apocalypse's "real" name. Inside a pyramid, some kind of ceremony is
going on involving a blue troll in sci-fi armor (that's Apocalypse) and L'il
Oscar Isaac, into whom the life essence (or "jism") of Apocalypse is
being transferred. Some guards in mascara make sex eyes at each other, after
which they execute a trap, bringing the pyramid down on the ceremony and dropping
Oscar Isaac, who has been transformed into the blue troll, into a pit so deep that
an entire scene happens while he's falling. How did they dig a pit so deep
using Bronze Age technology? How did they manage it without anybody knowing
about it? Why are they rebelling against Apocalype? And why does it all look
like an episode of Power Rangers
circa 1992? I don't know, and like most questions relating to character, logic,
and basic continuity, I don't think it ever occurred to anyone working on X-Men: Apocalypse to ask.
Then we jump forward to a high
school in 1983, where Scott Summers (Tye Sheridan), whom you may recall from
the original X-Men trilogy as Cyclops and/or James Marsden, is being a dick.
This will continue throughout the film, as Scott, like most everyone we'll
meet, is less a character than a single, easily identifiable trait to be harped
upon ad nauseam. That—and he has laser eyes. Scott might actually be one of the
better-rounded characters in that he gets a trait and a superpower. As far as I can tell, Angel's (Ben Hardy)
characterization is "has wings," and Moira McTaggart's (Rose Byrne)
is "got psychically roofied in X-Men:
First Class."
That, by the way—you know, James
McAvoy's Charles Xavier using his powers to make this woman forget months of
her life—is played mainly for laughs. They'll walk into a room, and she'll be
like, "This rooms seems familiar," and the other characters will
share a knowing smile, like, "Ha ha, you don't even know that we erased
your memories without your knowledge or consent, or even a quick discussion
first." At the end, when Xavier, for literally no reason other than the
fact that the movie's over, returns her memory, she just smiles at him. Like
it's no big deal that our "hero" stole her memory against her will
and then left it that way for decades.
Anyway, after 45 seconds of Scott
being a dick, we cut to Germany, where mutants are being forced to perform in
cage fights. Angel, whom you may recall "has wings," is the reigning
champion. He fights Nightcrawler (Kody Smit-McPhee) who, as one of the
primary characters, "teleports" and
"is Christian." The fight is broken up by Mystique (Jennifer
Lawrence), who rescues Nightcrawler, but not Angel. I know I'm beating a dead
horse, but there's no absolutely no reason for Angel to get left behind except
so he can become a villain later.
Then we cut to Poland, where Magneto
(Michael Fassbender) is working in a foundry under an assumed name. He has a
human wife and a daughter who talks to animals. Anyone who's ever seen an X-Men
movie will know that his family can't be long for this world, because Magneto's
long-standing characterization other than "magnet stuff" is "haz a sad." And, true to that, the wife and daughter die in the next scene
they're both in, impaled by a single arrow while they're hugging (the… irony?).
The movie goes on like that for
another two-plus hours, introducing way too many characters, bouncing them off
each other, and occasionally checking in with the plot, which can be succinctly
summarized as "Apocalypse wants to kill everyone," which takes a
while to get going because he recruits a bunch of underlings he
doesn't need. Why does he bother with hench-people when he spends most of the
movie warping reality by pointing at things? Because that's the plot. Why does he want to kill everyone? Because that's the plot.
Why does Quicksilver (Evan Peters) get involved? Because his scene was the best
part of Days of Future Past, and also
because that's the plot.
Credit where it's due: Quicksilver's
big action scene, in which he saves everyone in the Xavier School from an
explosion at super-speed, is once again a standout. Even that, though, is
predicated on a plot hole so big you could fly a Blackbird through it. He sees
Magneto (his biological father, depending upon whether you ask someone from
Marvel or Fox) on TV and goes to find Charles Xavier so he can ask him
Magneto-related questions. (The TV he's watching, by the way, is a flatscreen,
which nobody on set appears to have noticed despite the fact the film's only
visual motif is IT'S THE EIGHTIES.) When he arrives on the outskirts of the
school grounds, a good ¾ of a mile away, he cocks his head like a beagle hearing
a peanut butter jar being opened somewhere in its home, somehow sensing that
the school is about to explode so he can start getting everybody out.
There are countless contrivances
like that, and the 10,000th time (again, just an estimate) something
doesn't stand up to even cursory scrutiny, you start wishing you could ask,
"Do any of you even want to be here? Was anybody really champing at the
bit for an Apocalypse movie? Are you already starting to miss Hugh Jackman? I
know I am."
While I'm acknowledging the
positive, or at least less negative, aspects of the movie, Fassbender and
McAvoy do rise above the material to some extent, and I'm pretty sure Rose
Byrne would do so as well if Moira McTaggart had any reason to be in the movie
beyond the "hilarious" "comedy" of having had her agency
stripped away by a man she trusted. Among the younger generation, Kodi
Smit-McPhee is working his ass off to make Nightcrawler work and largely
succeeds, and Alexandra Shipp is likable as Storm, despite the great big
nothing-burger they both have to work with. Hugh Jackman shows up for 90
seconds as Weapon X Era Wolverine, and even with no dialogue and the world's worst
mullet wig, he almost manages to steal the show. Special credit to Evan Peters,
who, except for his signature scene, seems to know he's in a piece of shit and
relaying his lines sarcastically.
I could go on, but I'll leave you
with this, because I think it perfectly encapsulates how little of a shit X-Men: Apocalypse gives. There's a
post-credits scene in which a bunch of janitors are cleaning up the blood,
bodies, and shell casings left after our heroes toured the Weapon X facility
(all the characters go to Weapon X for a while, just so they could include that
90 seconds of Hugh Jackman, I think). But then, what's this? A nerdy science-type walks through carrying a steel briefcase! He walks down a few hallways, then
goes into what I suppose must be the employee break room, where he opens a
mini-fridge and pulls out a comically large vial labeled "WEAPON X
DNA" in what appears to be Comic Sans.
Fuck you, too, X-Men: Apocalypse. Fuck you, too.













